Stevens spent five seasons with Division II Maryville, starting in 2020, where he played just 12 games and bat .138. In 2021 appeared in 34 games as he bat .268 while launching seven home runs. Stevens returned for his junior season in 2022, where he played in 49 games and made 45 starts as he hit .328 and was named to the GLVC Second Team All-Conference and the ABCA/Rawlings Midwest All-Region Second Team. During the 2023 season, Stevens started all 56 games as he broke the school career and single-season home run records while batting .313 with 18 doubles, 64 RBI en route to a D2CCA All-America Honorable Mention and was named GLVC All-Conference First Team. In his final collegiate year in 2024, Stevens played in 59 games while batting .257 as he homered 24 times. Stevens played professionally in 2024 upon graduation, as he played in six games in the Frontier League for the Gateway Grizzlies while batting .191.